Skip to content
Search
Home
Collections
Events
Customization & Favors
Account
Site navigation
Search
Search
Cart
Menu
Site navigation
Home
Collections
Events
Customization & Favors
Account
Item added to cart.
View cart and check out
.
Close
Close
$5 Flat Rate Shipping or Orders Over $35
Close
Products – whatthesoap
Filter by
All
12496
3D Printed
70s
abalone
ABC
Accessories
Activated Charcoal
alchemy
Alcohol
All Natural
All Purpose
animal
Animals
anti-racist
apple
apron
art
Ash catcher
astrology
Bag
Bake
baked
Baking
bandeau
BBQ
bean
bear
Beekeeping
Beer
Beer Soap
bees
beeswax
Best Seller
beverage
big foot
biography
birdhouse
Birds
blanket
blaze
Body
Body Spray
boho
Book
bookmarks
Books
bosom
bottle opener
bowl
bracelets
Bread
brew
Bud
butter
camping
candle
candles
cane
Canning
canvas
car
card
cast iron
Cast Iron Soap Dishes
cat
catnip
Catskills
Cedar
ceramics
chaga
chain
Charcuterie
charms
Cheese
chef
Chickens
Children
Christmas
Cider
coaster
Cocktails
coconut
coffee
Coloring
condiments
constellations
Cook
Cookbook
Cooking
country
Cover
cow
cozie
Crafts
Crocheted
crystals
Curing
cushion
Cutting Boards
dead
dead head
dead sea mud
Decision
decor
Decoration
Deodorant
Disappearing
dish
dispenser
DIY
dogs
doll
drawing
duffel
earrings
earth
East
Eco Friendly
Edible
elegant
elephant
Elk
embroidery
enamelware
Essential Oil
ethical
Events & Classes
Exfoliating
Fabric Work
face
Facewash
Facial
Fair Trade
Faire
Family
Farm
Farming
felt
ferment
Fermentation
Field Guide
fire
Fish
Fishing
Flower
Foaming
Food
Foot Scrub
Forage
Foraging
forking
framed art
Fresh & Fun
frida
Fun
Funny
Game
games
Garden
Gardener
Gardening
garlic
gem
gemstone
gift
Gift Sets
gifts
gilboa
Glass
gnome
Goat's Milk
grateful dead
greeting
grill
grilling
ground
Guide
Habanero
hacky
hacky sack
hair
hair pins
Hand Soap
handbag
Handmade
happy
Hard Cider
hat
Headband
headwear
healing
health
hemp
Herbal
Herbalism
Herbalist
herbs
high
hiking
History
Holder
holiday
Holistic
Home
Home Decor
homemade
Homestead
Homesteading
Honey
Hot
Hot Sauce
houseplants
How To
hunter
Hypertufa
Incense
indigenous
ink
Insect Repellant
Insects
inspiration
jalapeno
jam
jelly
Jerky
Jewelry
Jungle
kahlo
Kids
kitchen
Knots
Landscape
Lavender
leather
Lemongrass
LGBTQ
Limited Edition
Lip Balm
Liquid Hand Soap
Liquid Soap
local
Local Author
Lotion Bar
luck
Macrame
magnet
mask
mead
meat
media
Medicine
mermaid
microwave
Milk Soap
mints
mix
Mixers
Mobile
mommy
monty python
Moose
Moringa Powder
Mosaic
Moths
mugs
multi media
Mushrooms
Mystery
mystical
Nag Champa
napkin
Native
native american
natural
Nature
necklace
New Release
New York
New York Made
newspaper
night sky
Northeast
not on amazon
NY Made
oatmeal
oil
OLD
Opium
oracle
orange
Organic
original
ornaments
ornithology
outdoors
painting
Palo Santo
pancakes
party
Patchouli
pen
perfume
Permaculture
pets
photography
pickle
Pickling
picture
pig
pillow
pins
planters
plants
plate
plushie
poetry
pork
potholder
pottery
pouch
Poultry
pratt
prattsville
Prepping
Preservation
Preserving
pride
pumpkin spice
purification
Purifying
Purse
Puzzle
puzzles
pyrography
Quilts
Rabbits
rainbow
Recipe
Recipes
Refill
retro
reuse
rings
ritual
roll-on
rustic
Sage
Salt
Sandalwood
Sauces
scents
schoharie
science
Sea Lark
Seasonal
selenite
Sensitive Skin
Shampoo
sign
Signs
skull
slivers
small batch
Smell
smoker
Smoking
smudge
smudging
snack
Soap Dish
Soap Dishes
soap ends
Soap Lift
socially conscious
Sourced Items
Spices
Spicy
spiritual
sponge
spooning
spread
Spring Scents
stainless steel
stamford
stargazing
stars
stash
sticker
sticky notes
stone
stoner
sugar
Sugar Scrub
summer
Survival
sustainability
syrup
t-lights
tarot
tea
tea bags
tea lights
tincture
tobacco
toothbrush holder
towel
towels
toy
Travel
treats
tree
Trees
tub
Tying
Unphil
Unscented
upcycled
Upstate
Vanilla
variety pack
Vegan
Venison
vinegar
vintage
waffles
Wallet
water
water color
wax
weed
wellness
What.The.Soap.
whatthesoap
Whipped Body Butter
White Sage
Wild
wildcrafted
wind
Wind Chime
windham
Winter
witchy
woke
women owned
Wood
wood burning
Woodwork
yogurt
zadock
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Moon Milk
Regular price
$8
View
Pine Tar Bar Soap
Regular price
$8.50
View
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
